The Laws Underneath  ·  Law 3 of 10

Giving and Receiving

You can receive something precisely to the extent you can give it, and give it precisely to the extent you can receive it.

Giving
Receiving
The moment

You close the all-hands by naming three people and what they pulled off this quarter. You meant every word. The room claps politely, and the Slack channel afterwards says nothing at all. Later, your chair tells you the board was impressed with how you handled the year, and you hear yourself thank her and move straight to the next item.

Underneath

Most leaders learn two things that contradict each other. First, people need to be seen; appreciation is oxygen; acknowledge your team. Second, needing appreciation yourself is weak; know your own value; be self-sufficient. A capable person takes both seriously, and the second one gets executed first. You remove your own need for recognition. It takes a few years, and it works: you don’t require anyone’s praise.

What you also did was make it impossible for anyone’s praise to make a difference. There’s no room for it to land, because you’ve arranged for there to be no need. And then, dutifully, you pay recognition out to the people who presumably haven’t yet reached the level of leadership you have.

Watch what that does to the recognition. You’ve classified the thing you’re giving as something a grown-up shouldn’t need, and it arrives in that category. Whatever you intend, it lands as a platitude. The law operates below intention, so meaning it doesn’t help. When you notice it isn’t landing, you do what capable people do: more of it, more forcefully, through grander mechanisms, a recognition program with its own budget line, and it still doesn’t land.

The pattern runs both directions and isn’t only about praise. The leader who finds giving feedback unpleasant, because it makes people feel bad, takes feedback through that same lens: with clenched teeth, as a report on how they currently suck, and either collapses into it or resists it. Neither is receiving. The same law runs through most of what a leader offers, trust (“I trust people; I just keep an eye out”) and forgiveness (“I forgive people; I just never let myself off the hook”) among them.

The way through isn’t to give more. It’s to come to terms with the plain fact that you rely on other people and need things from them, and to let that be true out loud. That’s what makes room for anything to land.

The test

What do you wish your team gave you more of: candour, credit, trust? When someone does offer it, what do you do with it?

Then look at how freely you give that same thing. The law says the two move together.

If this one was running in your last quarter, tell me. I’ll write back with what I’d look at.

Email Adam

or write to adam@adamquiney.com

The Laws Underneath

All ten laws

Hold each one up against your last quarter.

A Friday letter from Adam Quiney

The Blind Spot

One essay most Fridays, on leadership for the smartest person in the room.

Unsubscribe anytime.